What do Irish shoppers consider agriculture and animal welfare?

Evaluation: Shoppers have typically constructive views on animal welfare on Irish farms, however there’s a rising data hole on agricultural practices

Of Áine Regan And John HylandTeagasc

Animal welfare is more and more on the radar of Irish shoppers. Public perspective about how livestock are cared for can have a huge effect on meals buying developments. This contains finding out meals labels in grocery store aisles, altering consuming habits, or accessing native merchandise from brief meals provide chains, equivalent to farmers’ markets or season tickets for the supply of agricultural produce containers. The eye that customers pay to animal welfare practices on farms has the ability to affect the way forward for meals manufacturing in Eire.

To achieve a greater understanding of the general public’s data and opinion on this matter, the researchers interviewed practically 1,000 members of the general public. This revealed typically constructive public sentiment in regards to the welfare requirements of Irish and Northern Irish farms within the dairy, beef, pork and poultry sectors. Nonetheless, the outcomes confirmed variations in perceived welfare circumstances throughout sectors: better issues emerge for welfare in poultry and pork manufacturing, whereas decrease issues emerge for dairy and beef.

We want your consent to add this rte-player content materialWe use rte-player to handle additional content material that may set cookies in your machine and acquire information about your exercise. Please overview their particulars and settle for them to add the content material.Handle preferences

From RTÉ Radio 1’s Drivetime in 2020, Philip Boucher-Hayes experiences to an EU fee of inquiry into animal welfare requirements within the dwell export commerce

These sectoral variations are defined by a collection of things that customers have a tendency to make use of to evaluate the circumstances of well-being. In Eire and Northern Eire, cows and cattle are seen by the general public as a part of an prolonged grassland-based system with excessive public visibility leading to constructive perceptions of welfare. Quite the opposite, poultry and pig farms are thought of intensive, with poor public visibility with issues associated to housing and entry to the surface.

Throughout all sectors, nonetheless, the survey confirmed that the general public believes that welfare circumstances have improved over the previous decade. On the identical time, each the survey and the main focus teams confirmed that the general public feels uninformed about agricultural practices and doesn’t have sufficient data on wellness-friendly meals.

Analysis exhibits that there’s usually a niche between citizen issues and translation into buying conduct as a client. The challenge crew’s superior evaluation of the survey information shed additional mild on this citizen-consumer disconnect. By analyzing the members primarily based on their responses to varied aptitude questions, three profiles of typical shoppers have been recognized: “detached”, “dedicated” and “struggling”.

We want your consent to add this rte-player content materialWe use rte-player to handle additional content material that may set cookies in your machine and acquire information about your exercise. Please overview their particulars and settle for them to add the content material.Handle preferences

From RTÉ Information in 2016, animal welfare teams categorical anger at capturing 5 cattle on Monaghan farm

The “detached” client (69.1% of members) has a constructive notion of the welfare of livestock on the island of Eire. Whereas they really feel motivated to purchase wellness-friendly merchandise, this perspective is much less more likely to translate into frequent buying conduct.

The “dedicated” client (16.5% of members) could be very involved about welfare requirements in agriculture and is extremely motivated to buy merchandise conducive to welfare. Not like the ‘detached’ client, this motivation interprets into frequent shopping for conduct.

The patron “in problem” (14.4% of members) can also be involved in regards to the welfare requirements on farms. However whereas they’re motivated to purchase wellness-friendly merchandise, this motivation would not translate into conduct. Lack of selection, shortage of data, insufficient availability and problem in utilizing related labels signify important obstacles for this sort of client. Some of these shoppers will have to be supported by enablement-focused interventions, such because the institution of broadly accessible and dependable entrance labeling for wellness-friendly merchandise.

We want your consent to add this rte-player content materialWe use rte-player to handle additional content material that may set cookies in your machine and acquire information about your exercise. Please overview their particulars and settle for them to add the content material.Handle preferences

From RTÉ Radio 1’s Countrywide in 2020, Monaghan poultry farmer Mick McKenna on the results of avian flu on his farm and flock

Labeling can function an necessary platform for speaking welfare data and decreasing the hole between shoppers and farmers. However as audiences are extra uncovered to data throughout on-line and social media, there’s an in-depth evaluation of labels – what they are saying, what they imply, and the way a lot they are often trusted. Any labeling scheme have to be supported by a clear and evidence-based high quality assurance system to construct belief within the public.

Moreover, to make use of labels successfully, the general public will need to have an excellent understanding of agricultural and meals manufacturing practices. As shoppers declare to have little data on this topic, it’s clear that there’s an data hole referring to meals manufacturing and farm animal welfare.

Following the fieldwork with the general public, work was carried out to handle among the data wants that arose. By a co-design course of with veterinarians, animal welfare scientists, coverage makers, communications professionals and graphic designers, an animated whiteboard video was produced for most people. This makes use of compelling and publicly accessible details, languages ​​and pictures to speak what good welfare practices are in Irish dairy farms. It is a sector that has excessive financial and rural worth for Eire, however which can also be more and more underneath public scrutiny as a consequence of issues about sustainability.

We want your consent to add this YouTube content materialWe use YouTube to handle additional content material which can set cookies in your machine and acquire information about your exercise. Please overview their particulars and settle for them to add the content material.Handle preferences

The knowledge within the video goals to interrupt the rising disconnect between citizens-consumers and agriculture by offering folks with data of the facet of excellent agricultural practices. By studying about farm animal welfare and what this entails when it comes to farming practices, shoppers could make extra knowledgeable selections and be inspired to make use of meals labeling as a device to help accountable farm welfare practices.

This analysis was funded by the Division of Agriculture, Meals and Marine underneath the Analysis Stimulus Fund (challenge quantity: RSF 17 / S / 230).

Dr. Áine Regan is a Behavioral Scientist with Teagasc who works on nationwide and European initiatives on animal well being and welfare, the usage of digital applied sciences in agriculture and sustainable meals programs. Dr. John Hyland is a social science technologist with Teagasc with an curiosity in meals programs and sustainability in addition to determination making by farmers and shoppers.


The views expressed herein are these of the writer and don’t signify or replicate the views of RTÉ


Leave a Comment

A note to our visitors

This website has updated its privacy policy in compliance with changes to European Union data protection law, for all members globally. We’ve also updated our Privacy Policy to give you more information about your rights and responsibilities with respect to your privacy and personal information. Please read this to review the updates about which cookies we use and what information we collect on our site. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our updated privacy policy.